On what motivated the Crusaders

Christopher Tyerman dismisses the popular idea that the Crusades were about greed.

close

Summary

Christopher Tyerman dismisses the popular idea that the Crusades were about greed.

Transcript

There’s a traditional interpretation of the Crusades that they were simply land grabs. This is highly improbable. If you wanted to grab land – if you were a knight in France or Italy or Germany – if you wanted to grab land, why go 2,500 miles to a bare Judean hillside that actually was economically rubbish? There was a religious motivation. This didn’t preclude the fact that you were going to get spiritual rewards and probably material rewards – you were going to be paid to go, for example – but the cost, the initial capital outlay to go on crusade, was huge, many times a knight or a lord’s annual income. So this investment was very heavy. It’s hard to see many people making profits from simply going on crusade. There were attendant profits – if you did get land in the East, or if you were a shipper that had a contract with crusaders, etc. But the motive to going on a crusade was clearly not solely, or even mainly, material. There was this religious ideological purpose, it was “the right thing to do”.